Undercover investigation and fitness to practise
![Undercover investigation and fitness to practise](https://www.gdc-uk.org/images/default-source/homepage/gdc-banbury-2554100c49d46fe324fddb01815f3acfe0ebd.tmb-contentimg.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=5cd0c652_3)
In December 2019 we wrote about our use of undercover investigators in fitness to practise. It is a technique we used rarely in the past and have used still more rarely in recent years. We wrote then that there had been just 12 undercover visits over the previous three years, equating to just 0.2% of all concerns received over that same period. Since then, there has not been a single fitness to practise case where undercover visits have been used.
But in one of those past cases, we made a mistake. In planning an investigation in 2016, indeed the same investigation which led to the significant discussion on this issue 18 months ago, an undercover visit took place when the concern raised did not meet the threshold to warrant one. If it had been properly considered, the visit would not have taken place. In consequence of that, we agreed to pay compensation to the registrant concerned and to meet his legal costs, about £38,000 in total.
Our statutory framework requires us to investigate concerns that a registrant’s fitness to practise may be impaired. In doing this, undercover investigations are used as a last resort, when it is not possible to gather evidence in other ways and there is reason to believe that there may be a risk to patient safety. We have a robust process in place to assess risks to public health, safety and wellbeing, and this is designed to balance public protection with the rights of the individuals concerned.
The fact that no undercover fitness to practise investigations have taken place in recent years demonstrates that this is not a technique we use lightly, but we cannot rule out using it in the future where there is potential risk to the public, and where there is no other way to investigate a specific allegation that has been made.
What to read next…
![A view from the Chair: dental care professionals are renewing their registration, and we provide information about fitness to practise trends and what is reasonable in terms of clinical records](/images/default-source/about-us/toby-harris.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=c524de80_1)
![Lord Toby Harris](/images/default-source/about-us/lord-toby-harris-team.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=3fc10944_1)
Lord Toby Harris
03 July 2024
![Continuing professional development (CPD) myth-busting: helping DCPs navigate their CPD requirements](/images/default-source/news-and-blogs/col-s-dpa.tmb-thumbbox.png?Culture=en&sfvrsn=e994e1e5_1)
Continuing professional development (CPD) myth-busting: helping DCPs navigate their CPD requirements
![Dental Professional Alliance (DPA)](/images/default-source/news-and-blogs/col-s-dpa.tmb-authorico.png?Culture=en&sfvrsn=e994e1e5_1)
Dental Professional Alliance (DPA)
24 June 2024
![Dental record keeping: what is professional, reasonable and in the interest of patients?](/images/default-source/news-and-blogs/shamire3b3db39-ea1d-4b3c-a41c-f10a93879c38.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=a49e0aab_1)
![Shamir B. Mehta](/images/default-source/about-us/shamir-blog-pic.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=2100ca09_1)
Shamir B. Mehta
19 June 2024
![A view from the Chair: welcoming our new Chief Executive and getting on with delivering our priorities](/images/default-source/about-us/gdc__blu8047_lower2.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=f217c2cd_1)
![Lord Toby Harris](/images/default-source/about-us/lord-toby-harris-team.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=3fc10944_1)
Lord Toby Harris
05 June 2024
![A view from the Chair: International registration changes take effect and collaboration is key to provisional registration](/images/default-source/about-us/gdc__blu8047_lower2.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=f217c2cd_1)
![Lord Toby Harris](/images/default-source/about-us/lord-toby-harris-team.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=3fc10944_1)
Lord Toby Harris
07 March 2024
![Creating a personal development plan to deliver your professional learning and development needs](/images/default-source/about-us/ross.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=7d0cfaf4_1)
![Ross Scales](/images/default-source/about-us/ross-blogd1070a5f6b23415d820ff3c00f8ac0d3.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=854b96c1_3)
Ross Scales
29 January 2024
![A view from the Chair: Review of education, consulting on remote hearings and looking ahead to January](/images/default-source/about-us/gdc__blu8047_lower2.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=f217c2cd_1)
![Lord Toby Harris](/images/default-source/about-us/lord-toby-harris-team.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=3fc10944_1)
Lord Toby Harris
06 December 2023
![The Safe Practitioner: How we developed a new framework of behaviours and outcomes for dental professional education](/images/default-source/about-us/safe-practitioner.tmb-thumbbox.png?Culture=en&sfvrsn=a9d35a56_1)
Kathryn Counsell-Hubbard
05 December 2023
![A view from the Chair: Setting the ARF, understanding the dental workforce and sharing perspectives from patients and the public](/images/default-source/about-us/gdc__blu8047_lower2.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=f217c2cd_1)
![Lord Toby Harris](/images/default-source/about-us/lord-toby-harris-team.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=3fc10944_1)
Lord Toby Harris
31 October 2023
![A view from the Chair: Improving fitness to practise, exploring standards and welcoming new Council members](/images/default-source/about-us/gdc__blu8047_lower2.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=f217c2cd_1)
![Lord Toby Harris](/images/default-source/about-us/lord-toby-harris-team.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=3fc10944_1)
Lord Toby Harris
04 October 2023
![Building understanding: A year in review of our student and new registrant engagement programme](/images/default-source/about-us/capture.tmb-thumbbox.png?Culture=en&sfvrsn=1a8d79d2_2)
![Laura Bamford](/images/default-source/about-us/lb-image.tmb-authorico.png?Culture=en&sfvrsn=629da92f_1)
Laura Bamford
19 September 2023
![A view from the Chair: Maintaining the integrity of the registers and providing standards and guidance](/images/default-source/about-us/lord-toby-harris.tmb-thumbbox.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=4d7c8323_1)
![Lord Toby Harris](/images/default-source/about-us/lord-toby-harris-team.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=3fc10944_1)
Lord Toby Harris
06 September 2023
![Fitness to practise improvements: initial inquiries pilot launched](/images/default-source/about-us/gdc-thumbnailc4587961-5d86-4897-9fa0-ee6c8df885c7b3036bf4-b3e0-42ee-8434-39aa8d261933.tmb-thumbbox.png?Culture=en&sfvrsn=ef6d0310_4)
Fitness to practise improvements: initial inquiries pilot launched
![John Cullinane](/images/default-source/registration/john-cullinane97492b13793149cfaede1b56057a84c9.tmb-authorico.jpg?Culture=en&sfvrsn=87cca4bf_3)
John Cullinane
04 September 2023