What do we mean by right-touch regulation?

Dr Toby Ganley is the Head of Right Touch Regulation at the General Dental Council.
Most of us are aware of the six principles of right-touch regulation developed by the Professional Standards Authority (PSA), but how many of us can recite them or tell us what each of them means for dental regulation.
For some reason, the PSA shies away from the acronym PATCAT! I find it really helpful when trying to recall all six principles, which are:
- Proportionate
- Agile
- Targeted
- Consistent
- Accountable
- Transparent
But, remembering is only the start. What do they mean for us? What do they mean for dental regulation? These aren’t easy questions to answer.
Proportionate simply refers to a relationship or ratio between one thing and another – to achieve X, we invest Y - if someone does this type of thing, there will be a consequence of a particular kind. But, there’s a range of ways we
can interpret or define proportionate.
Accountable seems easier on the face of it. But accountable to who? The Privy Council? The public and patients? Dental professionals?
And, what space do we have for agility, within a rigid and dated legislative framework?
To explore these questions, we’ve recently embarked upon a new project to develop a set of principles to guide our regulatory decision making. We believe this will give confidence to those making decisions and provide clarity for dental professionals and the public. This will make it easier to know and understand the sorts of issues we are likely to focus on, and why, and the things that are outside of our scope.
We’ve only just begun, but we’ve started to get a feel for what some of the principles of right-touch regulation might mean for us. For example, those we’ve spoken to feel that proportionate should be linked to risk i.e. our intervention should be in proportion to the risks presented. This could work for how we consider targeted too i.e. actions are focused on where the risks reside. Agility might require us to find ways to be more flexible in our processes, while we continue to be constrained by regulation.
However, regulatory reform is now clearly on the government’s agenda. So, understanding and articulating these principles for dental regulation now, will mean we are very well positioned to respond to the opportunities this presents.
If onerous and rigid prescriptive legislation is replaced with greater autonomy, and accountability, we’ll have the flexibility we need to effectively and fairly apply our well-defined and understood set of principles. In the meantime, we will work to set out and define our principles in readiness for the reforms to come.
If this is subject of interest, and I hope it is, please be part of the conversation. There will be opportunities to help develop our thinking on our ‘principles of regulatory decision-making’, so keep an eye out and take advantage of them when you can.
What to read next…


Elizabeth Gonzalez Malaga
12 May 2022


Lord Toby Harris
04 May 2022


Lord Toby Harris
06 April 2022


Jyoti Sumel and Monica Matanda
23 March 2022

A view from the GDC's Chair: Good discussions and progress on international registration

Lord Toby Harris
02 March 2022


John Cullinane
24 February 2022


Jyoti Sumel and Monica Matanda
23 February 2022


Stefan Czerniawski
11 February 2022


Lord Toby Harris
02 February 2022


Daniel Knight
18 January 2022


Lord Toby Harris
05 January 2022


Kristen Bottrell
20 December 2021

The ORE: a flawed system made worse by the pandemic with further challenges ahead

Stefan Czerniawski
17 December 2021


Lord Toby Harris
01 December 2021


Caroline Lappin
30 November 2021


Stefan Czerniawski
25 November 2021


Gurvinder Soomal
22 October 2021


Black History Month
20 October 2021


Elizabeth Gonzalez Malaga
08 October 2021


John Cullinane
16 September 2021


Gurvinder Soomal
06 September 2021


Manjula Das
02 September 2021


Lisa Marie Williams
12 August 2021


Gordon Matheson CBE
04 August 2021

Helping patients to understand why face masks and social distancing is still in place at the dentist

John Cullinane
19 July 2021


Marie-Jeanne Royer
07 July 2021


Osama Ammar
10 June 2021