Close

Another one bites the dust: When a routine extraction goes wrong

19 November, 2026 by Shamir B. Mehta

We want to regulate in a way which promotes learning over fear, supporting dental professionals to continuously demonstrate professionalism, rather than driving behaviours through the threat of fitness to practise. Our role is to give clear, easy to use guidance that supports dental professionals to show good judgement and professional behaviour in providing good oral healthcare for patients and the public.  

This blog, Another one bites the dust: When a routine extraction goes wrong, is part of a series to support your learning and encourage good practice and continuous improvement to achieve positive patient outcomes.


Dental extractions are routinely prescribed for the management of dental disease and sometimes as part of broader treatment planning. NHS data recorded 56,143 extraction episodes among patients aged up to 19 years at NHS hospitals in England in the year ending 2025, with tooth decay accounting for 60.5% of all cases.1 Across both primary and secondary care, adult patients are likely to undergo more extractions.

As with any surgical procedure, dental extractions carry inherent risks. The irreversible outcome and the nature of this treatment mean that adverse outcomes can be particularly distressing for patients. GDC Fitness to Practise (FtP) data from 2025 highlights this concern. Among single-patient complaints, ‘extractions’ ranked joint second within the top five allegations at the earlier assessment stage of the FtP process (Stage 2), and third at the case examiner stage (Stage 3). At Stage 2, extractions and ‘orthodontics’ each accounted for 17% of the allegations in this category, and ‘examination’ accounted for 30%. 

Based on my experience as a GDC clinical dental adviser, complaints associated with dental extractions more commonly relate to:

  • Retained roots or tooth fragments
  • Failure to adequately manage pain, anxiety, or distress during treatment
  • Post-operative infection or delayed healing
  • Wrong-tooth extraction, or misunderstandings about the intended tooth for extraction
  • Oroantral communications and fistulae
  • Prescribing errors
  • Inferior alveolar or lingual nerve injury
  • Post-operative bleeding or alveolar osteitis (dry socket)
  • Dissatisfaction arising from poor communication or unexpected outcomes

In this blog, an illustrative case of a patient concern following a dental extraction is used to explore some of the recurring themes.

Case example

A 62-year-old female attended an emergency dental appointment with a newly recruited clinician at the practice – ‘Dentist 1’ - reporting a two-week history of severe toothache. Their clinical records documented:

  • A medical history update saying, “no changes since last visit”. The latter took place three months before.
  • A periapical radiograph showing a lower first molar tooth (LR6) with approximately 30% bone loss, slightly curved and bulbous roots, and a moderate sized carious (decay) lesion. However, the image quality was inadequate and did not fully reveal the neighbouring lower right second molar tooth (LR7).
  • A diagnosis of “hopeless prognosis”, for LR6, with extraction advised.
  • A discussion about the risk of a post-operative infection.

The patient was recorded as giving consent, and local anaesthetic was administered. The procedure was documented as a ‘routine extraction’. Post-operative instructions were given, with advice to revert in case of complications. There was no record of any challenges encountered. Amoxicillin (a Penicillin based antibiotic drug) was prescribed; however, the clinical rationale for this decision was not documented.

The patient’s past medical history forms listed a Penicillin allergy.

Later that evening, the patient attended a local Accident & Emergency department with severe pain and persistent bleeding. The attending clinician (‘Dentist 2’) noted that they were taking Rivaroxaban – a direct oral anticoagulant drug (blood thinner). A further radiograph confirmed complete extraction of LR6 but also showed that the distal (rear surface) of the adjacent LR7 tooth was grossly decayed. Sutures were placed, and further management was also provided.

Subsequently, the patient raised concerns about Dentist 1 with the GDC, including:

  • A poor standard of care, with Dentist 1 unresponsive to repeated requests to stop, as they had been experiencing severe pain throughout the procedure.
  • A procedure lasting 50 minutes. “Had I known it would feel like several rounds in a boxing ring, I would never have agreed to having it done.”
  • Failure to resolve their initial toothache.
  • Bleeding at the point of discharge.
  • Overlooking their medical history.
  • Dentist 2 told them that the incorrect tooth had been extracted.

Clinical adviser concern

On review of the clinical records and correspondence, the clinical adviser identified several areas of concern with the standard of care provided by Dentist 1:

Medical history and risk assessment - Although Dentist 1 recorded that the medical history had been updated, the entry only stated, “no changes since last visit”. Further information confirmed that the patient had begun Rivaroxaban seven weeks earlier, after their previous dental appointment, and believed this had been disclosed.

For a simple, single tooth extraction unlikely to cause prolonged bleeding complications, for a patient taking this drug and no other medical complications, post-operative bleeding risk is categorised as ‘low’2. SDCEP Guidance advises that such procedures can generally be undertaken without interruption of direct oral anticoagulant therapy2.  However, where a more complex extraction that would lead to a larger wound, or where surgical extraction is anticipated, requiring flap elevation, the post-operative risk of bleeding complications increases. Under these circumstances, Guidance recommends consideration of modifying anticoagulant management, including omission or delay of the morning dose on the day of treatment.

Regardless of risk category, best practice would have included scheduling treatment early in the day to allow for monitoring and management of possible bleeding complications, employing careful treatment technique with appropriate local haemostatic measures (including strongly considering suturing and packing where indicated), and providing clear post-operative instructions, including when and how to seek advice in the event of bleeding.2 Dentist 1’s records were deficient in these details.

Failure to identify anticoagulant use likely contributed to the post-operative bleeding and is a departure from safe clinical practice. Clinicians should actively verify medical histories, recognising that patients may not always volunteer significant changes without direct questioning. There is also the need to provide good quality care based on current evidence and authoritative guidance and any deviation from established practice and guidance should be justifiable and recorded.

Antimicrobial drug prescribing - Amoxicillin was prescribed despite a clearly documented Penicillin allergy. Although the medication was not dispensed, this represents a significant prescribing error with the potential for serious adverse consequences.

Furthermore, no clinical indication for antibiotic therapy was recorded. Current Guidance does not support the routine use of antibiotics following dental extractions for the prevention of surgical site infection, promotion of healing, or reduction of post-operative pain3. Antibiotics should usually be prescribed as an adjunct to local measures only where there is evidence of systemic involvement, spreading infection, or a raised temperature3.

Assessment, diagnosis, and record keeping – Dentist 1’s clinical records did not demonstrate a comprehensive assessment. Beyond a recorded history of pain and a periapical radiograph, there was no documentation of intra‑oral or extra‑oral findings to substantiate the diagnosis of a “hopeless” tooth.

In the absence of this level of detail, a third party cannot reliably assess the validity of the diagnosis or the appropriateness of the proposed treatment plan. While clinical records need not be exhaustive, they must be sufficiently clear, structured, and comprehensive to support clinical decision-making and enable continuity of care.

Radiographic assessment and treatment planning - Although a periapical radiograph was obtained, its diagnostic value was limited, as the adjacent LR7 tooth was not adequately visualised. LR7 was subsequently found to be grossly carious, raising the possibility of a diagnostic error and unnecessary intervention.

Consent, treatment planning - The patient alleged incorrect tooth extraction, based on the persistence of pain and their understanding of comments made by Dentist 2. However, the adviser did not find clear evidence to conclusively support a wrong‑tooth extraction. Notwithstanding this, the concern remains plausible given the limited diagnostic information recorded and the presence of significant pathology affecting the adjacent tooth. Even if the correct tooth was removed, the absence of clear documentation relating to diagnosis, prognosis, and discussion of alternative treatment options raised concerns about the validity of consent.

The validity of consent depends not simply on agreement to treatment, but on the patient understanding the diagnosis and the need for the proposed treatment, the available relevant treatment options, material risks, and likely outcomes. The more complex or irreversible the intervention, the greater the importance of documenting these discussions.

The radiograph demonstrated slightly curved and bulbous root morphology - features associated with increased extraction complexity. While the clinical adviser noted the imaging obtained by Dentist 2 confirmed complete removal of LR6, there was no record to say that the expected difficulty and associated risks were clearly communicated to the patient in a way they could understand. They had said, had they known, they would have asked for a referral to a specialist – a choice that was not given.

Taken together, these omissions represent a missed opportunity to manage patient expectations and to obtain fully informed consent.

Pain and anxiety management - The patient reported experiencing significant pain and distress during the procedure, including repeated requests for it to be stopped, and described Dentist 1 as lacking empathy and compassion. There is the need to always treat patients with dignity and respect. While patients may perceive pressure, vibration, and movement during extraction under local anaesthesia, higher levels of anxiety may amplify these sensations and lead them to be interpreted as pain. Nevertheless, reports of pain should always be taken seriously, prompting reassessment of the treatment plan before proceeding.

Good clinical practice would include confirming the adequacy of analgesia, documenting any difficulty in achieving effective analgesia, and pausing treatment to reassess where a patient reports ongoing discomfort. Evidence of clear and contemporaneous recording of these interactions is essential, particularly where the patient’s perception of pain could form a central component of a potential complaint.

Standard of extraction treatment - The patient described the extraction as lengthy and traumatic. The latter is a subjective matter, however, where procedures do not unfold as expected, clinicians should clearly document operative difficulties, complications encountered, additional techniques used, and discussions held with the patient. Such records are often critical when complaints arise, and they can assist colleagues, regulators, and independent reviewers in understanding what occurred.

Where a patient’s account could differ from the clinician’s records, additional contemporaneous documentation from the dental nurse assisting can provide an important supplementary perspective for any later third‑party review. In cases of conflicting evidence, the GDC may sometimes seek a statement of account from those present to help determine the facts.

Furthermore, there was no documentation to confirm that haemostasis was achieved prior to discharge. This represents a significant departure from expected standards of care, as both the achievement of haemostasis should be ensured and recorded following an extraction.

Complaints handling - The clinical adviser was critical of Dentist 1’s response to the complaint, describing it as defensive. Key concerns raised by the patient, particularly those relating to diagnosis, anticoagulant management, and inappropriate prescribing were inadequately addressed.

Overall views and likely early-stage case outcome

GDC clinical adviser assessments typically conclude that the standard of care provided is either,

  • at/ around
  • below, or
  • significantly below the standard that would reasonably be expected from a dental professional of the same discipline.

In some cases, incomplete or inadequate records may preclude a definitive determination.

When reviewed from a regulatory perspective, this case raises concerns across multiple domains of clinical practice, including assessment, consent, prescribing, record keeping, and patient-centred care. In this case, the presence of actual harm, the risk of serious potential harm, and the apparent failure to obtain valid informed consent would likely attract further significant professional scrutiny. These factors are commonly associated with progression beyond the assessment (Stage 2) to the case examiner stage (Stage 3). For further details, please refer to an article recently published in the British Dental Journal4.

Conclusion

Although most single-patient concerns reported to the GDC seldom progress beyond Stage 2, this case illustrates how multiple deficiencies can combine to create greater regulatory concern. Aspects of this case are often seen amongst concerns raised with the GDC about dental extractions.

Additional relevant reading:

References:

  1. Short statistical commentary for hospital tooth extractions in 0 to 19-year-olds 2025. Published 17 February 2026. https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/hospital-tooth-extractions-in-0-to-19-year-olds-2025/short-statistical-commentary-for-hospital-tooth-extractions-in-0-to-19-year-olds-2025
  2. SDCEP. Management of Dental Patients Taking Anticoagulants or Antiplatelet Drugs. Published March 2022 (2nd Edition) https://www.sdcep.org.uk/media/4gslzda1/sdcep-management-of-dental-patients-taking-anticoagulants-or-antiplatelet-drugs-2nd-edition.pdf
  3. CGDent. Antimicrobial prescribing in dentistry, Good Practice Guidelines (3rd Edition). https://cgdent.uk/antimicrobial-prescribing-in-dentistry/
  4. Mehta SB, Thayer T. The GDC and Fitness to Practise (FtP): recognition of the effects of a FtP investigation on registrants and attempts at tackling the climate of fear. Br Dent J. 2026 Jun;240(12):789-795. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41415-026-9615-9

What to read next…